Need a ruling from PPCLers

[iZeeshan]

So. We have a situation.

One of our released players wants to make a comeback.

Dadvoc: "Is it too late? I was taking care of my dadi and she just doesn't use computers or pay for WiFi"

Obviously we'd like to have another active player in our squad rather than an active one and we'd like to give him a chance to play as well, rather than play someone that's completely missing.

So I asked Rizzy if we could allow him back in the squad, and he does not have a problem with it, but wants the permission of PPCLers, which IMO is fair.

We want to release one of our players, KhurramJamil. (we have 18 already)

Move Desi to an E contract (give dadvoc a good enough contract to play)

Change dadvoc's player type (so dadvoc can play)

Give him a D (so dadvoc can actually get a shot in the XI)

Up to you guys - our team won't suffer in anyway technically, we'd just be allowing an active player to be part of our XI rather than an inactive one.

[Express Pace]

Bring him back!

[saj001]

Ok with us.

[aneeq7]

Please guys agree to it

btw. there should be a poll.

[I Believe in the Teesra]

Its cool with me.

[Fireworks11]

It's fine. Minor.

[Pakistaniboy]

I dont think anyone would mind.

Its Cool

[freelance_cricketer]

Cool with it.

[Ibad17]

no problem.

[iZeeshan]

What a wonderful bunch we have here, now hopefully dadvoc will actually be active now

[NJamal]

No problem whatsoever, green signal from The Outlawz.

[kingusama92]

Don't think anyone should mind.

Active players make the league better. I say, go for it!

[truthseer]

[shahidafridi123]

It's cool

[Watsupdoc]

Cool with it

[DeadlyVenom]

Sounds good to me

[Inswinger]

Nothing wrong with it.

[Express Pace]

No one will object, maybe also edit the first post, I doubt dadvoc wants us to all know his personal life.

[iZeeshan]

Originally Posted by Express Pace No one will object, maybe also edit the first post, I doubt dadvoc wants us to all know his personal life.

That was just a joke yaar, I have no idea what happened and why he wasn't online

[Express Pace]

Lol good one! I thought you were serious

[hefaith]

No problem

[DeadlyVenom]

Originally Posted by iZeeshan That was just a joke yaar, I have no idea what happened and why he wasn't online

Lolllll nice one.

[Ismailtoca]

sure, why not

[Canistani Hero]

Bring him back!

[withlovefrom vizag]

bring him baaaaacck

[sully3]

Great respect shown from you guys.. Respect that

[WiiiCKET]

No problem. Bring him back, give him whatever contract you want but do not agree on player change. Anyways my captain do not have a problem so carry on. It is just what i think.

[Space Cat]

Yea bring him back.

[iZeeshan]

Originally Posted by WiiiCKET No problem. Bring him back, give him whatever contract you want but do not agree on player change. Anyways my captain do not have a problem so carry on. It is just what i think.

you would be the only one to disagree

[WiiiCKET]

Originally Posted by iZeeshan you would be the only one to disagree

I do not disagree. You are allow to get him back in the team but do not agree with the player change. You are just taking too much advantage of his return.

Drafting back him in the team > changing contract > Releasing a player > changing a player type.

[iZeeshan]

Originally Posted by WiiiCKET I do not disagree. You are allow to get him back in the team but do not agree with the player change. You are just taking too much advantage of his return. Drafting back him in the team > Releasing a player > changing a player type. If you want to play him play him whatever he is now

yeah yeah yeah, it's your opinion whatever

I appreciate that everyone else doesn't mind as it will add an extra active player to the league.

I'm not taking advantage of anything, we'll be fine without him, but he wouldn't be part of the XI ever if he stayed the way he is.

[WiiiCKET]

If anyone else who is released and come back then say he will be active will create a mess. If one player is allowed then anyone else who is released should be allowed. Rizzy even didn't not allowed players to join even the most active ones after the deadline. My only concern is, if it is allowed for one then it should be allowed for everyone who comes and claim that they will be active. I have better suggestion. wait for one week and see how active he is. If you feel he is active then you have him otherwise continue as it was.

[iZeeshan]

Originally Posted by WiiiCKET If anyone else who is released and come back then say he will be active will create a mess. If one player is allowed then anyone else who is released should be allowed. Rizzy even didn't not allowed players to join even the most active ones after the deadline. My only concern is, if it is allowed for one then it should be allowed for everyone who comes and claim that they will be active. I have better suggestion. wait for one week and see how active he is. If you feel he is active then you have him otherwise continue as it was.

I honestly did not understand half of what you are trying to say.

I've made it clear what I wanted to do and why I wanted to do it, and everyone seems okay with it, and you're the only one causing trouble.

If everyone doesn't agree, then we don't have to do it - it won't really hurt me in anyway. Actually no I shouldn't say exactly that, it will slightly benefit me before I'll have more options, but our team can certainly live without it. However, if he stays as an RF then there's no point in even having this discussion because it won't matter that he's in the squad or not.

That's the end of that.

[aneeq7]

iZeeshan vs. WiiiCKET - Part 5



btw. WiiiCKET everyone seems to be okay with it, so just leave it.

[WiiiCKET]

Originally Posted by iZeeshan I honestly did not understand half of what you are trying to say. I've made it clear what I wanted to do and why I wanted to do it, and everyone seems okay with it, and you're the only one causing trouble. If everyone doesn't agree, then we don't have to do it - it won't really hurt me in anyway. That's the end of that.

In first part i am trying to say is that if tommrow some other release player comes and claim to be active. will he be allowed to play?

In second part i have suggestion for you. How sure are you that he is going to be active?

Lets just wait and see what Rizzy says..

[WiiiCKET]

Originally Posted by aneeq7 iZeeshan vs. WiiiCKET - Part 5 btw. WiiiCKET everyone seems to be okay with it, so just leave it.

Its ok with me because my captain do not have any problem with it. I am just telling what i think because OP says what PPCL players thinks.

[iZeeshan]

Originally Posted by WiiiCKET In first part i am trying to say is that if tommrow some other release player comes and claim to be active. will he be allowed to play? In second part i have suggestion for you. How sure are you that he is going to be active? Lets just wait and see what Rizzy says..

1. Please see my edited post.

2. I don't know - it's still early in the season, a game hasn't been played, contracts were just assigned, etc.

3. I don't - what's your point?

4. Rizzy already said he doesn't mind if I ask PPCL and they seem to be okay with it, which has already been proven

[WiiiCKET]

If everyone agree including Rizzy thinks its OK then carry on have him in your squad and do whatever you want.

[sully3]

Zeeshan i think you made a mistake here bro, rather then letting everyone in the league have a say you should just asked the captains. It was apparent that one or two were going to have a problem with this even if it makes them look petty !

[iZeeshan]

Nah man, it's okay I want the approval of everyone. It's better that way.

But WiiiCKET is the only one complaining whereas almost 20 ppl have approved it. So it shouldn't be a problem.

If it is, then whatever, let's move on.

[Prince of Pakistan]

We're fine with it.

[freelance_cricketer]

Originally Posted by Wi iCKET If anyone else who is released and come back then say he will be active will create a mess. If one player is allowed then anyone else who is released should be allowed. Rizzy even didn't not allowed players to join even the most active ones after the deadline. My only concern is, if it is allowed for one then it should be allowed for everyone who comes and claim that they will be active. I have better suggestion. wait for one week and see how active he is. If you feel he is active then you have him otherwise continue as it was.

[Space Cat]

the ramblings of a mad man.

[Square Drive]

All good.

[Ismailtoca]

Before we actually reject Wiiicket, just look at what he is saying


He is saying that by doing that DD gets another Player change, and that shouldnt be the case..

Its a valid argument.

A solution would be to give Dadvoc the player type of Khurram Jamil

[Genghis]

I believe we had a player change that we didn't use.

[iZeeshan]

Originally Posted by Ismailtoca Before we actually reject Wiiicket, just look at what he is saying He is saying that by doing that DD gets another Player change, and that shouldnt be the case.. Its a valid argument. A solution would be to give Dadvoc the player type of Khurram Jamil

Oh yeah I should have mentioned, we always had a 3rd player change.

[Inswinger]

Not a big issue. Just move on so we can start the season.

[Ismailtoca]

Originally Posted by iZeeshan Oh yeah I should have mentioned, we always had a 3rd player change.

Originally Posted by WiiiCKET I do not disagree. You are allow to get him back in the team but do not agree with the player change. You are just taking too much advantage of his return. Drafting back him in the team > changing contract > Releasing a player > changing a player type.

I dont think there is a problem now is there?

Everything is solved

[Sidcricfan]

No prob.